The hunt for the best proper pies in London

No mucking about... these are proper pies!

Mmmm, who can resist a sumptuous meaty filling in a bowl with a puff pastry lid?

EVERYONE.
Everyone can resist that - because it's not a proper pie!

A proper pie has pastry all around it, top and bottom - not just a faffy, flaky lid atop meat soup. When Marty Pellow sang "love is all around" it was an allegory for a pie. You are the meaty filling and love is pastry. Everyone knows that.

It's plain to see that we're pie pastry fascists here at AIL, so lucky for you, we've been on the hunt around London for some proper pies... and by Jove, we've found some!

Manze's image
Manze's
Cafes & Tea Rooms
204 Deptford High Street SE8 3PR
Deptford 0.09 miles
Opening Times
Best For

You can’t beat Manze’s for tradition, as this pie and mash shop has been in the Manze family for over a hundred years. Here the pies are served with liquor, which before you get overexcited is a parsley sauce rather than 40% proof booze. The menu also has jellied eels, the cockney classic everyone has to try at least once.

Castles image
Castles
Take Away Food Shops
229 Royal College Street NW1 9LT
Camden Road 0.03 miles
Opening Times
Best For

This is eating out the austerity-busting way thanks to a no-frills, greasy spoon-like interior and a small yet perfectly formed menu with pie and mash for £3.50 and a mug of tea for just 65p. Note that it only opens for lunch.

Putney Pies image
Putney Pies
British
2 Putney High Street SW15 1SL
Putney Bridge 0.27 miles
Photos
Best For
AIL
Users

This may be sacrilege to purists, but we’ll guiltily confess to liking the posh pies at this Putney restaurant. What pastry lover can resist venison and salami, pork belly with bacon and apple, and even a chili con carne pie with guacamole and Cheddar cheese? Plus you can complete the experience with a starter of “pie bites” and mini beef Wellingtons.

M Manze image
M Manze
Cafes & Tea Rooms
74 Chapel Market N1 9ER
Angel 0.12 miles
Opening Times
Best For

Not to be confused with Manze’s in Deptford, this is another century-old eatery serving up good old pie and mash at their three branches in Tower Bridge, Peckham and Sutton. Victoria and David Beckham have been known to pop in over the years, although we can’t vouch for Victoria’s portion size.

Harringtons image
Harringtons
Other
3 Selkirk Road SW17 0ER
Tooting Broadway 0.18 miles
Opening Times
Best For

We all know the grisly story of Sweeney Todd, the murderous barber with an accomplice who turned his victims into pies. Tooting Arts Club had the genius idea to stage Stephen Sondheim’s musical adaptation of the story at this very pie shop before relocating it to a venue on Shaftesbury Avenue. Fear not though, for the only filling you’ll find in these pies is wholesome minced beef, priced at an incredibly low £1.75.

Mother Mash image
Mother Mash
English
26 Ganton Street W1F 7QZ
Oxford Circus 0.17 miles
Opening Times
Best For

Poor mashed potato rarely gets the recognition it deserves, despite being a constant presence at the dinner tables for centuries. While mash is the specialty here, its natural accompaniment is the pie, and there’s Aberdeen Angus steak, chicken and leek, and Mediterranean roast veg to swirl your potato around.

G Kelly image
G Kelly
British
526 Roman Road E3 5ES
Bow Road 0.47 miles
Opening Times
Best For

When G Kelly opened in 1937 the aim was to provide a hearty lunch to the local market traders on Roman Road. Nearly 80 years later they continue to make pies fresh each day, as well as hot and jellied eels to hungry Eastenders, although their one concession to modern times is the meat-free pie made with soya mince.

Piebury Corner image
Piebury Corner
British
209-211 Holloway Road N7 8DL
Holloway Road 0.16 miles
Opening Times
Must Try
Best For

This Islington deli began life as a food stall to appease the hunger of football fans at Arsenal’s stadium nearby. They’ve since perfected and expanded their range to include veggie options like goat’s cheese and sweet potato, and adventurous pies like jerk chicken and lamb with mint.

Battersea Pie Station image
Battersea Pie Station
Cafes & Coffee Shops
28 The Market WC2E 8RA
Covent Garden 0.08 miles
Best For

As well as having a permanent home in Covent Garden’s market, Battersea Pie Station pops up at festivals like Glastonbury and Bestival. As well as classic hot and cold pies they offer pasties and gloopy puddings.

Stolle image
Stolle
Cafes & Coffee Shops
45 - 47 Parkway NW1 7PN
Camden Town 0.13 miles
Best For

There’s no denying Britain’s reputation when it comes to making a good pie, particularly in the north of England, however central European nations like Austria and Germany are also a deft hand at pastry-making. Stolle takes its cue from these countries with savoury fillings like cabbage, chicken and spring onion, and indulgent deep-filled sweet pies with blueberry, strawberry and plum. Order by the slice or push the boat out and buy a kilo.

Sign up for the latest
Sign up to our newsletter for the latest and greatest from London!
By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive email updates and newsletters from All In London. You can unsubscribe at any time.